Even Odds Pizza

4.3 (78 reviews )
$$
Pizza restaurant
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in
Lunch
+(8)

About Even Odds Pizza

At Even Odds Pizza, located in Grafton, Wisconsin, pizza is more than just a meal—it's a community experience. Our story begins with a commitment to crafting exceptional, mouthwatering pizzas using fresh, high-quality ingredients. Guests can choose from our hand-tossed or rustic thin-crust options and indulge in a variety of unique toppings and sauces, including our signature Eo sauces. We pride ourselves on providing not just delicious flavors but also a warm, inviting atmosphere where families and friends gather. By actively supporting local causes, we strive to give back to the community that supports us. At Even Odds, it's always about great pizza and good fortune shared.

Reviews (78) 4.3

  • Noemi L.
    Apr 6,2025

    Admittedly, I'm a pizza snob. I can't help it, I was born & raised in Connecticut, which happens to be the Pizza Capital of the USA. So trust me when I say that Even Odds Pizza has the BEST tasting pizza pies, not only in Grafton, but all of Ozaukee and Milwaukee Counties. It's seriously the closest thing to the apizzas from back home that I've found outside of CT. Everything, from the dough/crust, sauce, cheese and toppings, are *chef's kiss* delicious. Fresh tasting, cooked perfectly, and they're the only pizza place out here that will cut the pie into TRIANGLE SLICES (as they should be!) and not squares. My favorite Even Odds order is their rustic thin crust BBQ Chicken pizza. They load up on the toppings but you don't have to worry about it falling apart on you. That rustic thin crust is solid and holds up well. No floppy, gloppy crusts here! Their classic hand tossed pizzas are phenomenal, as well. It's the only place that my daughter will eat the crusts from. Another thing about Even Odds that I love is that they're very involved in helping the community. They are involved in all the "Dine to Donate" fundraising events held by local schools, non-profits, and other local programs. If you're considering pizza for any occasion, whether it's a kid's birthday party, employee appreciation party, or casual night at home, consider ordering from Even Odds! You'll be glad you did!

  • Phyllis W.
    Jan 4,2025

    This pizza is amazing. The delivery is great. My pizzas always arrive early and hot! The flavors are great. The ingredients are fresh and abundant. Portions are worth the money! This is a great pizza -- like I remember pizzas tasting when I was a kid. So worth waiting for!!!

  • Celeste M.
    Oct 7,2024

    Called in a pizza order and got the pizza within 20 minutes! It was fresh and tasty! Thin crust with a nice sauce and plenty of cheese. $13 for a medium with 3 toppings! Two meals for me! Would definitely order again.

Frequently Asked Questions

  • What are the popular dishes at Even Odds Pizza?

    Even Odds Pizza is known for its delicious specialty pizzas like the Meatball Madness and Buffalo Chicken, as well as a fantastic selection of Detroit-style pizzas.

  • Do I need to make a reservation at Even Odds Pizza?

    Reservations are accepted, but walk-ins are also welcome, making it easy to enjoy a meal whenever you're in the mood for pizza!

  • Can I dine in or only get takeout at this restaurant?

    You can enjoy your meal in-house or opt for takeout; both options are available at Even Odds Pizza.

  • What is the atmosphere like at Even Odds Pizza?

    The restaurant has a casual vibe, making it a great spot for lunch or dinner with friends and family. It's also wheelchair accessible for your convenience.

  • Is parking available at Even Odds Pizza?

    Yes! There’s free parking available in the lot as well as free street parking nearby.

Nearby Pizza restaurants

Pizza restaurant
Enzos Pizza

464 E Geneva St Elkhorn, WI 53121 United States

Pizza restaurant
Prime Time Pizza

1765 Park Ave Beloit, WI 53511 United States

Are you the owner?

Claim this page to update business information and manage your presence.

Claim this page Claim this page